بازشناخت و تحلیل سبک شناسی سردیس های منسوب به دورۀ اشکانی در موزۀ هنر جهان تهران: تأثیرات بین فرهنگی در هنر پیکرتراشی ایران باستان (مقاله علمی وزارت علوم)
درجه علمی: نشریه علمی (وزارت علوم)
آرشیو
چکیده
دوره اشکانی، یکی از ادوار تاریخی پُر رمز و راز و در عین حال تأثیرگذار در تاریخ هنر ایران است که ویژگی بارز آن التقاط فرهنگی و هنری میان سنت های بومی و نفوذ عناصر خارجی، به ویژه هلنی، میان رودانی و آسیای شرقی می باشد. در موزه هنر جهان تهران مجموعه ای شامل هشت سردیس سنگی نگه داری می شود که به دوره اشکانی نسبت داده شده اند؛ اما فقدان مستندات دقیق، کاوش های علمی و اطلاعات باستان شناختی مربوط به محل کشف یا زمینه های فرهنگی این آثار، هویت و نسبت زمانی آن ها را با چالش مواجه کرده است. این پژوهش با رویکرد توصیفی-تحلیلی و برمبنای مقایسه تطبیقی، درپی آن است تا از خلال عناصر سبک شناختی، ویژگی های شمایل نگاری، فرم های پیکره سازی و جزئیات اجرایی، جایگاه زمانی و فرهنگی این سردیس ها را بازشناسد. یافته های پژوهش نشان می دهد که این سردیس ها ازمنظر فن ساخت، مواد به کار رفته، و ویژگی های ظاهری ازجمله: چیدمان مو، فرم چشم ها، ابعاد بینی، حالت دهان، و تزئینات سر، با نمونه هایی از نواحی مختلف قلمرو اشکانی، مانند: نسا، هترا، دورا-اوروپوس و حتی برخی مناطق شرقی، مانند بلخ، قابل مقایسه اند. به عنوان نمونه، وجود فرم چشم های بادامی و کشیده در برخی سردیس ها، مؤید تأثیرات هنر شرقی، و در مقابل حالت چهره طبیعی و موهای فرفری در نمونه های دیگر، گویای استمرار سنت های هلنیستی در بستر فرهنگی ایران است؛ هم چنین عناصر بومی ایرانی نظیر: بینی برجسته، سبیل های بلند و گونه های استخوانی، در ساخت این سردیس ها به وضوح مشاهده می شود. نتیجه گیری پژوهش بر آن است که این سردیس ها هرچند در ظاهر منسوب به دوره اشکانی هستند، اما در باطن، ترکیبی غنی از لایه های فرهنگی و هنری چندگانه را در خود دارند که بازتاب دهنده ماهیت سیال و فرامرزی هنر این دوره است. بازخوانی این آثار می تواند به درک عمیق تری از روند شکل گیری هویت تصویری ایرانی در دوران میانه تاریخ ایران و نحوه مواجهه هنرمندان آن زمان با جریان های هنری وارداتی بی انجامد.Recognition and Stylistic Analysis of Busts Attributed to the Parthian Period in the Tehran Museum of World Art: Cross-Cultural Influences in Ancient Iranian Sculpture
The Parthian period represents one of the most enigmatic yet influential eras in the history of Iranian art, marked by a distinctive cultural and artistic syncretism. This period witnessed a fusion of indigenous traditions with external influences, particularly Hellenistic, Mesopotamian, and Eastern of Iran elements. The Tehran Museum of World Art houses a collection of eight stone busts attributed to the Parthian era. However, the absence of precise documentation, scientific excavations, and archaeological data regarding their provenance and cultural context has cast doubt on their identity and chronological attribution. This study, employing a descriptive-analytical approach and comparative stylistic analysis, aims to reassess the temporal and cultural positioning of these busts through examination of iconographic features, sculptural forms, stylistic elements, and technical details. The findings suggest that these busts, in terms of craftsmanship, material composition, and visual characteristics-such as hair arrangement, eye shape, nasal structure, mouth expression, and head ornamentation-are comparable to examples from various regions of the Parthian realm, including Nisa, Hatra, Dura-Europos, and even Bactria in eastern Iran. For instance, the presence of elongated almond-shaped eyes in certain busts reflects Eastern artistic influence, while naturalistic facial expressions and curly hair in others indicate the persistence of Hellenistic traditions within the Iranian cultural sphere. Indigenous Iranian elements such as prominent noses, long mustaches, and high cheekbones are also distinctly visible in their construction. The study concludes that although these busts are outwardly attributed to the Parthian era, they inherently embody a rich amalgamation of multiple cultural and artistic layers. This hybridity reflects the transregional and fluid nature of Parthian art. Reinterpreting these artifacts may contribute to a deeper understanding of the development of Iranian visual identity during the middle periods of its history, as well as the ways in which contemporary artists engaged with incoming artistic currents.
Keywords: Parthians, Sculpture, Tehran Museum of World Art.
Introduction
Sculpture, as one of the oldest forms of human cultural expression, has always reflected the beliefs, social structures, and intercultural dynamics of societies (Qaderi et al., 2015:39). Across different historical contexts, statues were created not only to honor deities and kings but also to preserve the likeness and identity of ordinary individuals (Colburn, 2014:773). In Iran, the art of sculpture entered a new phase with the arrival of the Seleucids and the expansion of Hellenistic influence. Subsequently, with the rise of the Parthians and their efforts to revive Iranian cultural identity, this art form underwent a profound transformation (Lukonin & Ivanov, 2015).
The artistic style of the Parthian period can be seen as a complex synthesis of Iranian, Hellenistic, Mesopotamian, and even Central Asian elements (Pierfrancesco, 2015:12). Especially in the later centuries of Parthian rule, a conscious shift away from Greek realism toward indigenous and traditional Iranian features is evident-a transition that not only redefined the sculptural style but also contributed to the emergence of a distinct syncretic visual identity (Hauser, 2012:1001; Genito, 2019:73).
By examining the stylistic evolution across three main phases-initial Hellenistic influence, fusion with native elements, and eventual reassertion of authentic Iranian features-it is possible to trace the gradual formation of Parthian art. In this process, early political and military challenges, especially the expansionist nature of Parthian rule, hindered cultural unity and instead fostered a multilayered artistic output enriched by diverse influences from conquered regions (Sinisi, 2020:9; Kiani, 2012:110; Colburn, 2023).
A notable feature of Parthian sculpture is the inclusion of commoners alongside royal and divine figures-perhaps an indication of broader social participation in artistic production or greater accessibility to representational art across social classes (Colledge, 1979:221). Within this context, eight busts attributed to the Parthian period, currently housed in the Tehran Museum of World Art, are the focus of this study. These works exhibit a blend of Hellenistic, Mesopotamian, East Iran, and Achaemenid elements, while also reflecting a distinctly Iranian identity. The primary objectives of this research are: to identify the artistic styles and techniques used in these stone and plaster sculptures; to understand the cultural and historical contexts of their production; and to analyze the symbolic and religious significance of the depicted themes and motifs.
Key research questions include: To which historical period do the busts attributed to the Seleucid-Parthian era in the Museum belong? Which cultures do they represent?
Discussion
The Tehran Museum of World Art houses eight busts attributed to the Parthian period which, despite their historical and artistic significance, have yet to be the subject of a systematic academic study. Their identification relies solely on minimal museum labels, and there is no available information regarding their provenance, typology, or stylistic analysis. This research, for the first time, presents a comparative and analytical examination of these busts.
A notable aspect of Parthian sculpture is its inherently hybrid nature, shaped through interactions with neighboring cultures and artistic traditions. Due to their unique geographical position-situated at the crossroads of East and West-the Parthians functioned as cultural mediators, giving rise to a dynamic, multi-layered artistic identity. Hellenistic culture, in particular, left a profound imprint on Parthian sculpture, promoting a tendency toward realism and the creation of lifelike representations. However, Parthian art was not merely a passive recipient of Greek influence; rather, it actively synthesized and reinterpreted diverse cultural inputs. In Parthian artistic production, Hellenistic realism coexisted with Eastern symbolic expression, resulting in a distinctive aesthetic that blended classical naturalism with local iconography. The empire’s proximity to Mesopotamia, the Indus Valley, Central Asia, and the Hellenized western regions contributed to a wide spectrum of stylistic influences. This cultural diversity is clearly reflected in the sculptural features of the busts under study. Together, these busts illustrate the stylistic pluralism and layered identity of Parthian sculpture, bridging various cultural realms while maintaining an underlying Iranian essence. The busts include depictions of both male and female figures of varying ages and characteristics.
Conclusion
Sculpture, beyond being a mere aesthetic tool, has served as a symbolic and propagandistic medium fundamental to reinforcing and promoting social values, beliefs, and political agendas. In the context of Parthian sculpture, due to the unprecedented territorial expanse of the empire and the diversity of ethnic groups and cultures under its dominion, the artworks reflect a complex, multilayered, and intertwined cultural and artistic identity formed through a sophisticated fusion of diverse influences.
The early Parthian period coincided with the dominance of Hellenistic culture, which spread widely following Alexander the Great’s conquests and became the prevailing artistic current across much of the East. Distinctive features of this culture in sculpture include a strong emphasis on realism, meticulous attention to facial details, soft and natural body contours, and hairstyles and clothing styles derived from Greek traditions. These traits are clearly visible in the early Parthian busts, indicating deep and comprehensive Hellenistic influence. As noted by Qaderi and Khademi Nedoushan (2006:89), “the Parthians entered a domain previously ruled by Macedonian-Greek Seleucids whose influence persisted, and even after gaining independence, major surrounding powers remained Hellenized... thus, it is unsurprising that these desert dwellers and their cultural sphere exhibit strong Hellenistic influences.#8221;
Over time, as Parthian power consolidated, artists increasingly integrated authentic Iranian and regional elements. The thick, curly beards of men, symbolizing authority and social status in Iranian culture, stand in contrast to the clean-shaven faces typical of Greek art. Additionally, Mesopotamian influences are evident, particularly in women’s headgear and male cap styles, reflecting the extensive cultural interactions within the multiethnic Parthian empire. Asian and eastern Iranian characteristics are also traceable in certain hairstyles and facial forms, indicating broad engagement with eastern peoples and reciprocal cultural exchange.
The study of the eight previously undocumented busts at the Tehran Museum of World Art vividly illustrates this complex and intelligent cultural amalgamation. Despite apparent differences, these works share extensive similarities in technical composition, subject selection, and the representation of cultural identity, demonstrating a convergent and synergistic artistic approach during the Parthian era.
تبلیغات
