تحلیل تحولات تاریخی و محتوایی مجلۀ «اثر» (مقاله علمی وزارت علوم)
درجه علمی: نشریه علمی (وزارت علوم)
آرشیو
چکیده
هدف این پژوهش، بررسی تحلیلی سیر تاریخی و تحولات محتوایی مقالات منتشر شده در فصلنامه علمی «اثر» بین سال های 1393 تا 1403ه .ش. است؛ هم چنین، این مطالعه به ارزیابی میزان هم سویی مقالات با نیازهای روز و اولویت های حوزه حفاظت و مرمت می پردازد. این پژوهش با استفاده از رویکردهای علم سنجی، تبارشناسی و تحلیل روند، تعداد 303 مقاله را در بازه زمانی موردنظر بررسی کرده است. داده های کتاب شناختی شامل اطلاعات نویسندگان، موضوعات، روش های پژوهش، کلمات کلیدی و شبکه های همکاری علمی جمع آوری و با استفاده از نرم افزار ATLAS.ti تحلیل شده اند. یافته ها نشان می دهد که مجله «اثر» از ثبات نسبی در تعداد و تنوع موضوعی مقالات برخوردار بوده و عمدتاً بر مباحث اجتماعی، تاریخی و معماری تمرکز داشته است. با این وجود به بخش های اجتماعی و زیست محیطی توجه بیشتری شده است؛ از سویی دیگر، موضوعاتی مانند فناوری های نوین (مانند دیجیتال سازی و مدل سازی رایانه ای) و ابعاد اقتصادی حوزه مرمت کمتر موردتوجه قرار گرفته اند. شبکه همکاری علمی نشان دهنده نقش محوری پژوهشگاه میراث فرهنگی و گردشگری است، اما تعامل با نهادهای صنعتی و سازمان های دولتی هم چنان محدود است. این پژوهش نتیجه گیری می کند که مجله «اثر» جایگاه تثبیت شده ای در حوزه حفاظت و مرمت دارد؛ اما برای پاسخ گویی به نیازهای درحال ظهور و ارتقا جایگاه بین المللی خود، لازم است همکاری های میان رشته ای و بین المللی را تقویت کرده و به موضوعات کمتر پرداخته شده، به ویژه موضوعات فناوری های نوین و اقتصاد میراث فرهنگی، بیشتر توجه کند.Analysis of the Historical and Content Developments of Asar Journal
This study investigates the historical trends, thematic developments, and scholarly collaboration patterns in articles published by the Asar Scientific Journal from 2014 to 2024 (1393-1403 in the Iranian calendar). By analyzing 303 published articles, the research seeks to determine the degree to which the journal’s content aligns with contemporary priorities in heritage conservation and restoration. Using a combined approach of scientometrics and content analysis, data were collected on authorship, institutional affiliations, keywords, methodologies, and collaboration structures, and analyzed using ATLAS.ti software. The findings indicate a relative stability in publication frequency, with a peak in 2022 (42 articles) and a low point in 2016 (22 articles). Thematic analysis shows a predominance of social, historical, and architectural studies, while technological and economic aspects remain underexplored. For context, only one article in the entire decade focused on economics, while technology-related papers rarely engaged with modern digital applications. Geographically, most contributions originate from Iran, particularly Isfahan, Tehran, and East Azerbaijan, although limited international comparisons with Turkey, China, and Russia were also observed. Collaboration networks reveal the central role of the Cultural Heritage and Tourism Research Institute, supported by universities such as Islamic Azad University and Isfahan University of Art. However, engagement with industry and governmental bodies remains limited, highlighting a gap between research and policy. Overall, while Asar demonstrates strong academic visibility, future growth depends on expanding its thematic scope to include economic dimensions, technological innovation, and pressing national challenges such as water scarcity and climate change. Strengthening international collaborations and diversifying methodological approaches could further enhance the journal’s contribution to sustainable heritage conservation and increase its real-world impact.
Keywords: Scientometrics, Asar Journal, Historical Heritage Conservation and Restoration, Scientific Collaboration Networks, Emerging Research Trends, Scholarly Genealogy, PESTEL Model.
Introduction
The Asar Journal, published by the Research Institute of Cultural Heritage and Tourism in Iran, represents one of the most influential academic platforms for the dissemination of knowledge in heritage conservation, restoration, architecture, and related cultural studies. As the first specialized journal in this field established after the Islamic Revolution, and holding a “B” rating from the Ministry of Science alongside an ISC classification, its academic standing is well-established. Since its establishment, the journal has played a critical role in shaping scholarly debates within the national context, while also contributing to broader regional dialogues. Yet, despite its longstanding reputation, there has been limited systematic investigation into how effectively the journal reflects the evolving needs of both academia and society. This is particularly crucial in the face of pressing national and global challenges such as climate change, water scarcity, urban transformation, and the integration of digital technologies into heritage management. This study addresses this research gap by examining the journal’s alignment with these contemporary priorities.
In the last decade, the academic publishing landscape in Iran has undergone significant transformation, mirroring global trends. Growing internationalization, the digitalization of research outputs, and the increasing importance of scientometric and genealogical analyses have compelled journals to adapt their editorial policies and thematic orientations. In this regard, evaluating the thematic evolution of
Asar is essential for understanding its responsiveness to emerging scientific, cultural, and social priorities. A genealogical approach, inspired by Foucault, allows for a deeper analysis of the historical processes and intellectual shifts that have shaped the knowledge produced within its pages. The journal’s potential role extends beyond academic discourse; it can serve as a vital bridge between researchers, policymakers, and practitioners in heritage conservation, thereby contributing to sustainable cultural development. The effectiveness of this role, however, depends on its ability to foster diverse collaborations and address practical, real-world problems.
The present study, therefore, aims to conduct a comprehensive scientometric and genealogical analysis of
Asar over a ten-year period (2014-2024) to address three main objectives. First, it analyzes the historical trends and content changes to evaluate the journal’s role in knowledge dissemination. Second, it assesses the alignment of published articles with the current needs and priorities of the heritage sector. Third, it examines the degree of theoretical coherence or diversity within the journal’s publications. By applying analytical frameworks, including a PESTEL analysis, the research seeks to identify strengths and weaknesses in the journal’s thematic coverage across political, economic, social, technological, environmental, and legal dimensions. In doing so, the study provides evidence-based insights and strategic recommendations that may guide future editorial strategies and enhance the journal’s impact in both national and international contexts.
Discussion
This analysis of 303 articles from the Asar journal confirms its established position in Iranian academia while simultaneously revealing critical areas for strategic development. The findings illustrate a significant thematic imbalance, which, when viewed through the PESTEL framework, shows a clear concentration on social, historical, and environmental dimensions. While this focus reflects traditional strengths in humanities research, the pronounced underrepresentation of economic and modern technological topics points to a potential disconnects with key contemporary challenges in heritage management. The scarcity of research on topics like project budgeting or the economic impacts of conservation, alongside the limited engagement with crucial technologies such as digitalization and 3D scanning, suggests that the journal may not be fully equipping its readership to address the practical and financial realities of sustainable heritage development.
Methodologically, the predominance of qualitative and case-study approaches is consistent with the nature of heritage studies but also presents a limitation. This homogeneity may restrict the generalizability of findings and inhibit broader comparative analysis. To enhance the robustness of its published research, the journal could benefit from actively encouraging a greater diversity of research designs, particularly the integration of analytical or mixed-methods approaches that can provide more generalizable insights.
The analysis of collaboration networks highlights another crucial gap: the disconnect between academic research and its practical application. While the Cultural Heritage and Tourism Research Institute serves as a strong central hub for academic collaboration, the limited engagement with governmental and industrial sectors is a significant weakness. This finding suggests that the valuable knowledge produced within the journal’s pages may not be effectively translated into actionable policies or industry practices. Fostering stronger, formalized partnerships between researchers, policymakers, and industry professionals is therefore essential for bridging this gap and maximizing the real-world impact of the research.
Finally, the study reveals that academic output is not produced in a vacuum; publication trends appear to be influenced by the broader socio-political context within Iran. This interconnectedness underscores the journal’s potential to serve as a chronicler of national priorities and challenges. By strategically diversifying its thematic scope, promoting methodological innovation, and fostering cross-sectoral collaborations, the Asar journal can evolve from a respected academic repository into a more dynamic and influential force in shaping the future of sustainable heritage conservation.
Conclusion
This study concludes that while the “Asar” Scientific Journal has an established position within the field of heritage conservation and restoration in Iran, it possesses significant untapped potential for academic growth and broader impact. The research found that the journal has maintained a relative stability in its publication output over the past decade, with a peak of 42 articles in 2022 and a low of 22 in 2016, and a strong thematic focus on social, historical, and architectural topics. However, there is a clear opportunity to expand its scope by addressing emerging research needs and contemporary national priorities, such as environmental crises and the need for economic sustainability.
Specifically, the findings highlight those topics related to modern technologies, such as digitization and computer modeling, along with the economic dimensions of cultural heritage, have received comparatively limited attention. To better address the real needs of the conservation field and contribute meaningfully to sustainable development, future research published in the journal should prioritize these underrepresented areas. Furthermore, the analysis of the scientific collaboration network revealed that while the Cultural Heritage and Tourism Research Institute plays a central role with 17 key collaborations, interaction with industrial entities and governmental organizations remains limited, indicating a gap between academic research and practical application. The research also pointed to a methodological homogeneity, with a majority of studies employing qualitative approaches, suggesting a need for greater diversity through the inclusion of mixed-methods research.
To enhance the journal’s scholarly impact and its competitiveness on both national and international fronts, it is essential to foster stronger partnerships with non-academic stakeholders. By strategically creating special issues focused on technological innovation and the economics of cultural heritage, promoting methodological diversity, and bridging the gap between researchers and policymakers, the journal can better serve the academic and professional communities. Such efforts will allow “Asar” to contribute more effectively to the sustainable and resilient conservation of Iran’s invaluable cultural heritage in the face of contemporary challenges.
تبلیغات
