Level of proficiency

Errors are one of the enigmatic parts in the process of foreign language (L2) learning as they are extremely versatile at each and every stage of the language learning proficiency. The present study, therefore, was an attempt to reveal Iranian EFL learners’ grammatical errors in writing at two levels of proficiency, namely lower intermediate and advanced, and then to investigate whether there was a relationship between the levels of EFL learners’ proficiency and the types of grammatical errors they committed in their scripts. The study was carried out at a private language institute in Gorgan, Iran. To this end, 60 female EFL learners (30 lower intermediate and 30 advanced females) whose age ranged between 13 and 17 participated in this study and wrote 150 word writing samples on a predetermined descriptive subject. The descriptive analyses of the data based on the scoring framework of the study demonstrated the types of grammatical errors at each level of proficiency. A Chi Square test was then run in SPSS Ver. 25 on the 16 common frequent error categories between both levels of proficiency, which verified the existence of a relationship between EFL learners’ levels of proficiency and the types of written grammatical errors they committed in their writing. The findings of the study might be of interest to EFL learners, EFL teachers, syllabus designers, and materials developers.

پژوهش حاضر به بررسی تاثیر داده محور بر تشخیص و تولید هم آیی ها ی زبان آموزان با سطح توانش انگلیسی بالا و پایین متوسط پرداخت. همچنین تاثیر ثانویه داده محور بر هم آیی های ثانویه (هم آیی هایی که در واژه یاب گنجانده نشده بودند ولی به صورت مستتر در تکالیف استفاده شده بودند) نیز مورد بررسی قرار گرفت. نگرش زبان آموزان نسبت به نقش واژه یاب در یادگیری هم آیی ها و تغییر نگرش آنها در طی فرایند پژوهش نیز از طریق مصاحبه مورد ارزیابی قرار گرفت. حدود 40 زبان آموز ایرانی به دو گروه آزمایشی و گواه تقسیم شدند. هر گروه به دو زیرگروه سطح توانش بالا و پایین نیز تقسیم شدند. گروه آزمایشی به مدت 10 جلسه به واژه یاب دسترسی داشتند تا تکلیف دوباره نویسی را انجام دهند. نتایج حاکی از آن است که زبان آموزان با سطح توانش بالا بیشتر از زبان آموزان با سطح توانش پایین از تاثیر اولیه و ثانویه واژه یاب بهره مند شدند. هر دو زیرگروه، نگرش مثبتی به تاثیر واژه یاب در یادگیری هم آیی ها داشتند و این نگرش با گذر زمان پررنگتر شد.

Although processing instruction (PI) has been a very popular grammar teaching method over the last years, there are, however, very limited if any attempts to explore different proficiency learners’ achievements using this approach. This study was, therefore, an attempt to investigate the role of PI in possibly bringing about enhanced acquisition of three grammatical structures: regular past tense, causatives and relative clauses. In addition, it sought learner’s attitudes towards PI as it is believed that the success of an approach is highly dependent upon the viewpoints of its practitioners and the students being exposed to it. Three proficiency groups of elementary (n = 42), intermediate (n = 38) and advanced (n = 40) EFL learners were compared. The results of a set of independent samples t-tests revealed significant effects for the use of PI in all the groups except for a lack of improvement for elementary learners’ production of the regular past tense structure. The analysis of the attitude questionnaire and learners’ further ideas on the effectiveness of PI revealed their appreciation of the integration of this instructional practice in their target language courses. The results are discussed in relation to effective grammar and writing pedagogy.